PC Mag. reviews Weaknees

« BBC Internet Media Player (IMP) | Main | Canadian review of Beyond TV »

PC Mag. reviews Weaknees

PC Magazine does a review of the Weaknees Tivo upgrade and comes away impressed, but not enough to keep the upgrade.

Here's something else I learned during my TiVo experience: I don't love TV enough to want TiVo or the service. If I miss an episode of Friends, I'm not crushed. If I have to watch something for a few moments to figure out what it is, I'm OK with that.

TiVo is a revolution, or at least part of one. Now there are so many PVR/DVR choices, including Media Center PCs, and we're starting to see units that fit as neatly into the home theater environment as the TiVo. Ultimately, all the minor quibbles I have will fade away. I envision a day when my TV will have TiVo capabilities, and I won't need a separate device to time-shift or pick up channel information.

I do think this reviewer has an important point. Most people will be happy enough with less-than-Tivo's-featureset if they don't have to pay the upfront and monthly fees. The cable and satellite providers who are adding PVR features to their boxes and adding a few dollars to the monthly bill will be tough to beat.

For those people who love TV, and want all of the best features and the easiest user-experience will pay for Tivo, but it's clear that that particular market is not nearly as big as Tivo had hoped.

The Real TiVo: A Supercharged Personal Video Recorder That Still Has Flaws [abcnews.go.com]

by Gen Kanai March 1, 2004 in Product Reviews

Comments

$13/month is pretty outrageous for what you're getting. Where is TitanTV, for example, getting its data?

Posted by: pb at Mar 1, 2004 11:25:27 PM

For me, TiVo represents saving the opportunity cost of all the time I'd lose to arguments if I forgot to tape all the episodes of "Gilmore Girls" for my wife. Medical bills, too. $13/mo is better than extra health coverage + marriage counseling. :)

Posted by: Joe Taylor at Mar 2, 2004 2:13:39 PM

Someone needs to send that man a DirecTivo setup to review. It would eliminate the majority of his objections. A stand-alone Tivo unit is 'nice' but a DirecTivo setup is wonderful.

Posted by: JSG at Mar 3, 2004 12:45:08 PM

FYI...Dish Network now has an offer for new customers where you can get a 921 for $600 with a 1-year HDTV commitment. This is a pretty darn good deal.

Posted by: Rick Forman at Mar 25, 2004 11:08:16 AM

Wonderful work. I enjoyed read your site a lot.

casin

Posted by: casin at May 19, 2004 11:13:16 AM

PC Mag. reviews Weaknees

Comments

Post a Comment

On this site

Recent Comments

Advertising